在线国产一区二区_成人黄色片在线观看_国产成人免费_日韩精品免费在线视频_亚洲精品美女久久_欧美一级免费在线观看

US EUROPE AFRICA ASIA 中文
Business / Industries

Anti-trust team lacks real muscle for enforcement

By Zhao Yinan (China Daily) Updated: 2014-08-18 04:25

Despite sweeping probes into antitrust cases, China's antitrust team - government law enforcement officers and lawyers representing companies - is falling short in dealing with complicated cases.

While legal experts agree that government regulators have made good progress in investigation and law enforcement since China passed its Anti-Monopoly Law in 2008, penalties are sometimes inconsistent and enforcement lacks the capability to challenge the dominant State-owned enterprises.

Fines issued by local bureaus of the State Administration of Industry and Commerce in 2013 vary from place to place, even though they target the same industry with similar monopolistic practices, according to a five-year review by Beijing Lawyers Association.

The fines, usually about 1 percent of the company's revenues in the past year, are much lower than those issued by the National Development and Reform Commission, another government law enforcement agency, whose fines can top 10 percent, the report said.

Wang Xiaoye, an antitrust law professor at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences' Institute of Law, rebutted speculation that the ongoing probes are targeting foreign companies.

"If we take a review over the past six years, instead of focusing on the recent years, the three government regulators have investigated more domestic companies than foreign companies," Wang said.

But she said government regulators can feel constrained when dealing with SOEs and administrative monopoly, a monopolistic practice posed by a public power.

The official status of the three government regulators is lower than many heavyweight SOEs, which leaves them vulnerable when probing cases.

The NDRC's probe into China's two largest telecom companies has yet to make a ruling since its start in 2011.

A shortage of manpower also hinders regulators from looking into bigger cases.

Although the three agencies have all expanded over the years, their teams are dwarfed compared with counterparts in the EU and the United States, where thousands of law enforcement officers work to keep market competition fair.

The NDRC's price supervision and anti-monopoly bureau expanded its staff from 20 to 46 in 2011.

Meanwhile, eight provincial areas, including Beijing, are allowed to recruit a total of 150 antitrust officers in local NDRC offices to strengthen law enforcement ability at the grassroots level.

The Ministry of Commerce, one of China's antitrust regulators, also recruited more staff to top up the review of mergers and acquisitions.

Sun Shaosong, a partner in Beijing's Guantao Law Firm, said more domestic lawyers have been working in the field since 2008.

"Chinese lawyers are proficient in fundamental antitrust work such as compliance, M&A and antitrust investigation," Sun said. "But we are usually less competitive when it involves more speculative thinking and economic calculation."

Sun said the capability gap is because European and US lawyers, in general, have seen more cases, while China only introduced its Anti-Monopoly Law six years ago.

Ning Xuanfeng, a senior antitrust lawyer and partner of King & Wood Mallesons, suggested more law schools in China should set up anti-monopoly branches to nurture young talent.

Anti-trust team lacks real muscle for enforcement

Anti-trust team lacks real muscle for enforcement

Consumer concerns core of the issue Qualcomm denies financial links with Chinese expert

Hot Topics

Editor's Picks
...
...
主站蜘蛛池模板: 日韩精品在线免费观看 | 看黄网址| 4438成人网 | 国产美女在线播放 | 午夜精品久久 | www.青青草.com | 久久精品一区二区国产 | 日本免费不卡视频 | 国产一区高清 | 在线观看视频国产 | 国产一级视频在线观看 | 免费一级黄色录像 | 日韩在线视频播放 | 日韩在线播放视频 | 亚洲成人精品在线 | 日本天堂在线 | 久久国语| 日韩三级中文字幕 | 日韩欧美高清 | 日韩视频在线免费观看 | 青青艹在线视频 | 亚洲福利专区 | 国产一级生活片 | 久久精品欧美一区二区 | 天天碰天天操 | 好色影院| 成人免费视频国产免费麻豆 | 欧美激情在线播放 | 在线观看小视频 | 成年人午夜视频 | 国产传媒一区二区 | 日韩精品视频免费在线观看 | 黄色在线观看免费 | 97久久久久 | 99re这里只有精品6 | 好吊视频一区二区三区四区 | 精品久久久久久一区二区里番 | 一区二区三区四区精品 | 免费视频黄 | 亚洲一级免费视频 | 成人网在线 |